As I've said above, only in long-term attraction. For flings and one-night-stands, it's going to be all looks.
I can agree with that. For flings or bar hook up, looks are extremely important. However, bars and clubs are not the only places to meet nice women. From what I have seen, average looking men have far better chance to date women through their network, for example women at work or school or the ones they meet through friends.